Sunroof drain Class Action Lawsuit
#11
Audiworld Junior Member
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Washington, DC
Posts: 70
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Avant roof-rack attachments aren't sealed well. Not uncommon to see water/rust stains in the headliner near those anchor points...as can easily be seen in our 2K A6 Avant.
#12
Poor connecitons consist of an adapter between the hose and the sunroof drain nipple. These adapters separate from the hose and leak. I used some RTV to seal it and added a hose clamp for belt and suspenders.
#13
Bet other companies don't have sunroof drain cleaning in their manual...Oh yea, my second 5000 the timing belt was not listed as a maintenance item in the manual, but did fail at 120K hmmmmmmm. (Only an easy fix valve job required). Did the laywers miss an opportunity or, was I just ignorant?
Another day in paradise
Cheers
#15
Floydo:
Not so.
Got a letter from Mercedes Benz this past year for the same thing on MY2003 S-Class.
Water ingress at sunroof and cabin air plenum from clogged reed valves drains. The "reed valve" is just a drain nipple with a rubber flapper on the end to allow water to drizzle out, but not to splash in.
Suggested action fr MB: clear out air plenum and sunroof drain holes of leaves and debris, unclog reed vavles. Includes reimbursement for carpet/interior trim repair.
It must be a German thing. I recall my mother-in-law's 87 BMW 325 had same issue. Soaked passenger footwell after heavy rain or carwash. Problem: clogged reed valve drain in passenger air plenum. Accessible in engine compartment on the firewall, below the windshield on passenger side.
Not so.
Got a letter from Mercedes Benz this past year for the same thing on MY2003 S-Class.
Water ingress at sunroof and cabin air plenum from clogged reed valves drains. The "reed valve" is just a drain nipple with a rubber flapper on the end to allow water to drizzle out, but not to splash in.
Suggested action fr MB: clear out air plenum and sunroof drain holes of leaves and debris, unclog reed vavles. Includes reimbursement for carpet/interior trim repair.
It must be a German thing. I recall my mother-in-law's 87 BMW 325 had same issue. Soaked passenger footwell after heavy rain or carwash. Problem: clogged reed valve drain in passenger air plenum. Accessible in engine compartment on the firewall, below the windshield on passenger side.
#17
AudiWorld Member
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Mt Baldy, CA
Posts: 227
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Here's my problem with this whole shenaniganz
Having had issues with leaks that water-logged my TCU, and leaking pillars, I think I can speak up here. At the time, I couldn't help but be amazed at the terribly stupid design of the "water-drain" system. However, I have absolutely no desire to demand any compensation from Audi.
Several reasons:
Everyone that asks me "How do you like your Audi" pretty much gets a car-dealer ear full from me about what a bitchin' vehicle it is. Of course I know it's not perfect but I still pretend it is. So I have a problem being an unpaid advertiser and loyal fan of this company, and then turning around and accusing them of poor design. When I compare the rest of the car's design to the stupid drainage systems, I think they already more than compensate. Their main engineering feats are to focus on the car's performance. Nobody walked into the C5 design meeting one day and said "Okay guys, let's really put our heads together on this one... We need an excess water drainage system that is flawless and puts all our competition to shame".
Second of all, I am a firm believer that every owner should know their car very well. For whatever reason, when I first got this car I was not doing near the research that I should have on this forum. If I had, I might have known that these leaks could be future issues, and I should have investigated and taken care of them.
Most everyone on here is aware of the leak issues. We can say all we want "how were we supposed to know?" But the truth is, the information is out there, among other sites besides this forum, I am sure. Since the information is available, it is up to the owner to utilize this information and make drain-checks part of their regular maintenance schedule.
Similarly, you don't know when a tire is going to go blow out. Does Audi have to tell everyone "check your tires regularly for bald spots, bubbles, etc."? No. It is common knowledge, just as the leaks are basically common knowledge among VW and Audi owners at this point.
Several reasons:
Everyone that asks me "How do you like your Audi" pretty much gets a car-dealer ear full from me about what a bitchin' vehicle it is. Of course I know it's not perfect but I still pretend it is. So I have a problem being an unpaid advertiser and loyal fan of this company, and then turning around and accusing them of poor design. When I compare the rest of the car's design to the stupid drainage systems, I think they already more than compensate. Their main engineering feats are to focus on the car's performance. Nobody walked into the C5 design meeting one day and said "Okay guys, let's really put our heads together on this one... We need an excess water drainage system that is flawless and puts all our competition to shame".
Second of all, I am a firm believer that every owner should know their car very well. For whatever reason, when I first got this car I was not doing near the research that I should have on this forum. If I had, I might have known that these leaks could be future issues, and I should have investigated and taken care of them.
Most everyone on here is aware of the leak issues. We can say all we want "how were we supposed to know?" But the truth is, the information is out there, among other sites besides this forum, I am sure. Since the information is available, it is up to the owner to utilize this information and make drain-checks part of their regular maintenance schedule.
Similarly, you don't know when a tire is going to go blow out. Does Audi have to tell everyone "check your tires regularly for bald spots, bubbles, etc."? No. It is common knowledge, just as the leaks are basically common knowledge among VW and Audi owners at this point.
#18
Audiworld Junior Member
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: WA
Posts: 23
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Of course they are not addressing the poor connectors at the rear of the sunroof shelf, and I don't think there's any reimbursement for the 2 hours I spent putting a hose clamp on the loose fitting and the bottle of Resolve to clean the stains on the c/d pillar trim.
No proof of damages...
No proof of damages...
#19
AudiWorld Super User
LOL--reed valves. I just changed plugs in my M3 and part of the process was removal of the the plenum that contains the charcoal air filter...on E46 M3 it's smack dab in the middle of the engine compartment right below the windshield. Anyway, on the M3 there are TWO drains, each about an inch in diameter, look like little elbows facing down and back toward the firewall. And these elbows have a flap on them that essentially serves as a reed valve/one-way valve to allow stuff to drain onto the back of the engine but no engine compartment fumes, etc. to back up into the plenum.
Part of the problem with the audi reed valves seems to be they are not large enough to get the crap out as well as the water, I don't think that's unusual given the space to work with and the size of the tubes from the sunroof.
Part of the problem with the audi reed valves seems to be they are not large enough to get the crap out as well as the water, I don't think that's unusual given the space to work with and the size of the tubes from the sunroof.
#20
It is likely that the connector to your sunroof drain has cracked and is leaking. You can seal up the crack with RTV and put a tiny hose clamp to secure it.
search this forum on my name johnkk and find a 4-10-2009 thread on sunroof drains. It has my write up and some pics from others.
Technically you are supposed to drop the headliner, but I was able to partially lower the headliner on the passenger side without taking everything out. You do have to remove the C/D pillar trim and loosen the B pillar trim at the top. Go to the tech resources section and find the headliner article by Boston Driver. While you don't have to drop the headliner, he gives good detailed instructions on the C/C pillar removal.
Be very careful when you pull down the headliner a couple of inches to to access the drain connection. The headliner can crease easily, but I had no problems.
Resolve carpet cleaner did a good job of cleaning up the stains on the trim.
search this forum on my name johnkk and find a 4-10-2009 thread on sunroof drains. It has my write up and some pics from others.
Technically you are supposed to drop the headliner, but I was able to partially lower the headliner on the passenger side without taking everything out. You do have to remove the C/D pillar trim and loosen the B pillar trim at the top. Go to the tech resources section and find the headliner article by Boston Driver. While you don't have to drop the headliner, he gives good detailed instructions on the C/C pillar removal.
Be very careful when you pull down the headliner a couple of inches to to access the drain connection. The headliner can crease easily, but I had no problems.
Resolve carpet cleaner did a good job of cleaning up the stains on the trim.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
motorwaffen
A4 (B6 Platform) Discussion
17
04-28-2003 05:52 PM