bhwrice

I recently picked up a 2006 (B6) A4 3.0 in manual, my dream car. Unfortunately last weekend some idiot t-boned me, and the car is a total loss. I went back to where I got my A4 and test drove some 3 and 5 series, as well as a volvo s60 R and the cars in the subject line. All were nice cars, but I remained impressed by the smooth ride, and quiet cabin in the audis.

All of the subject cars are within my price range (depending on miles). Does anyone have something to say for the 3.2 over the 4.2, or 3.0? I still have not had a chance to drive the S4 in manual, will that be a big jump from the 3.0 I am used to?

Ben

CharlieG

In a word ... YES.

FastMarkA

I'd get the S4 in a heartbeat over the B6/B7 A4s.

(Of course the A4s are still great cars.)

bhwrice

I don't think I've ever driven a car in which it was more fun to have a automatic, however I haven't been in something with this much power. Should I consider it?

CharlieG

Personally, I would go with the six-speed if you can find one. Then again, I never drove the S4 with the tiptronic either. My wife has had the tip in both a 3.0L & 2.0T A4 Avant and I was never very impressed with it but they had considerably less power than the S4. In any form the S4 is a fantastic ride. Best of luck with your choice!

bhwrice

Thanks for the feedback guys!

rabidclimber

Great question. I am now in the same scenario. What was your final choice and whats your feedback now having driven both? Also thiughtsnon the tip vs manual ( iv always driven manuals untill I came to new zealand now im not sure if flapynpaddels will be nice or never used. Thanks for your time/ responces. Nick

bhwrice

I bought a B6 S4, best choice I ever made. Manual all the way!

That being said, the deal I made with myself is that I would do any/all major maintenance and repair work myself. If you aren't comfortable with this, please be aware that this car will cost you money.